/rta/ - Religion and Philosophy

Board for discussions related to Dharma.

International /int/ board is now open for non IndiNow non Indian posters who are not using vpn or pr...
Happy Holi🌾 Have a safe and fun festival 🌾 ...
Going back to BasicsAs we discussed and shared earlier, I am going bac...
[View Noticeboard]
0/4000

[All][RED]
BharatChan Disclaimer

Notice

Before proceeding, please read and understand the following:

1. BharatChan is a user-generated content platform. The site owners do not claim responsibility for posts made by users.

2. By accessing this website, you acknowledge that content may not be suitable for all audiences.

3. You must follow BharatChan’s community guidelines and rules. Failure to do so may result in a ban.

4. By using BharatChan users agree to the use of cookies, mostly for session related to user.

A poster on BharatChan must abide by the following rules:

Sitewide Rules
You must be 18 or older to post.
Sharing personal details or engaging in doxing is strictly prohibited.
Political discussions should be confined to /pol/.
Off-topic discussions, thread derailment, or spam may result in a ban and IP blacklist.
Pornographic content is strictly prohibited.
Any activity violating local laws is not allowed.
If you are not an Indian, you can only post in /int/. Or create and account and ask for approval to post in other boards.
Acknowledge

Recent Posts

View

View

View

Why Cattle Are Considered Sacred in Hinduism: Hist...

View

Opinions on Picrel

View

View

View

View

Some artwork I made using AI

View

Is Indra considered the Supreme God In vedic hindu...

View

How do I worship Dyaus Pitr?

View

Who is your isht Devi/devta?

View

View

View

Decline of the vedic faith

What caused this?

View

goes hard

View

Opinions ?

View

Why do Chintus celebrate Brahmahatya ?

View

I can recite this by Heart.

View

View

Which sect are you most attracted to ?

View

bhagwat geeta

View

View

View

Tripundra general

View

View

do you have faith in Bhagvad Gita ?

View

View

View

View

View

Opinions on Rasa Panchadhyayi ?

View

View

indranons zara idhar aana

View

Caste is a Western Construct ....

View

View

Does God Exist?

View

Hindus are doomed

View

Varnashrama

View

What is that "One Book(s)" that everyone should re...

View

Post Indian normiecore

View

christianity

View

watch this jain baba bragging about jains exploiti...

View

View

To all my Musleem Bhachanners

View

As a Dalit I envy the feeling of religiosity among...

View

Ashwamedha Yagya

View

some betichods who sold the religion for cheap rew...

View

If a muslimahh ties you rakhi should one assume sh...

View

View

White Judaeo-Christian <-> Steppe people <-> Mongol pipeline

CH

mmmod2

No.69

White Judaeo-Christian <-> Steppe (PIE) people <-> Mongolian aesthetic pipeline

You will notice that there are more and more people larping as Proto-Indo-Europeans (PIE) on different platforms. These are usually people that want the West to dissassociate from Christianity- so they resort to creating a fantastical PIE culture (many of these people are btw from Russia as well). These people are usually also into Heathenry ( which means LARPing as pagans even though they are culturally completely judaeo-christian).

"Proto indo european" is actually circular - because they are called that based on the assumption that Indoeuropeans originated from groups that came from there - so every finding of bones is ascribed to that group which was supposed to prove that they come from there.

There is actually nothing known about them - apart from some bones, jewelry (which they most likely didn't make themselves), simple tools, so even calling them that is highly debatable - at best they are just nomadic tribes who lived in Steppe regions.

Because the people who want to claim PIE as their "own" actually aren't very creative - the aesthetics of the art they are creating/created so far , is interstingly pushed into the direction of the Mongolians knowingly/subconsciously (who are one of the last two big nomadic groups alive , the other one being various African nomads , who of course these people in general do not like to associate with or even know much about to begin with)

Mongolians never developed anything on their own (no complex religion, no scripture or complex language) and neither do nomadic groups in general.

Anonymous

IN

NJEl0N

No.70

>>69(OP)

Steppe Theory is bunk.

We just need some indic groups to put together the already out research into a proper summary.

>R1 indian haplogroup can be explained by CHG and J2

>IVC was already civilization with vedic characteristics

>CHG / Iran_N and Iran_HG relationship and how admix of either three peak in Indian subcont.

Cultures being shared around the western north iran. Iran - IVC - BMAC link.

Also, this is more suited for >>>/sa/hitya which covers literature and history tbh.

Anonymous

IN

NJEl0N

No.71

>>70

At this point i have rough draft of my own based on explanations n times.

If I get time i will refine it further.

CH

mmmod2

No.72

>>70

https://adnaera.com/2024/12/08/origins-and-spread-of-indo-european-languages-an-alternative-view/

Active Users in /rta/: N/A