Recent Posts
Change my mind
qKrtII
No.393432
Privatize everything except for government and law. By everything i mean EVERYTHING.
>bureaucracy
Give contracts to pvt companies to do the management. More pvt cities and towns
>army
Service on contract (expand agnipath). Private arms industry.
>police
Privatize
>banks
>railways
everything privatized
1ckPeL
No.393434
>>393432(OP)
agree with all except army and police, hard keys to power should remain in state's control
eBBPmg
No.393436
>>393432(OP)
>Give contracts to pvt companies to do the management. More pvt cities and towns
>>army
>Service on contract (expand agnipath). Private arms industry.
>>police
Acha
gEySKx
No.393437
>>393432(OP)
+ 1
Institutes will be independent of government, hence no reservation which means much better efficiency
0/1O58
No.393440
Not one politician have the courage of being openly Capitalist.
Lundia is not USA, they like being backward, weak and sabka sath, lode ka vikas.
1nPVzL
No.393441
>>393432(OP)
ANCAP is based
0/1O58
No.393443
Whi will fund Ladli lund yojana and 100 other Bhangi Chamar welfare schemes?
qKrtII
No.393447
>>393437
Also, free market competition will incentivize performance. You dont do your job you get replaced. You do better you are rewarded. You dont get to be a lethargic babu.
WtepVc
No.393465
>>393434
State will still stay in charge. Its just that service will be contractual with pvt companies competing for contracts with government.
1nPVzL
No.393477
>>393441
ANCAP is the rational future for a spacefaring human civilization. Every (indian)/clan/tribes going their own way in the vast expanse of universe settling planets and colonizing alien species.
BWY+4Q
No.393481
>>393432(OP)
Privatization is only good if there is competition in market but with time due to merger or acquisitions only 1 or 2 big players remain
bFMZnp
No.393490
>>393432(OP)
pull sapot
1ckPeL
No.393492
>>393465
Yea we know how trustworthy mercs are... mercs should be avoided until the last resort!.
1ckPeL
No.393498
>>393492
maybe the police could work tho...
9SqNnH
No.393503
>>393465
look at what happened in Sudan
WtepVc
No.393511
>>393481
Monopolies and dupolies arise when government hinders free market. You had oligarchy back in license raj days when only the cronies could do business. Free market actually prevents monopolies.
1ckPeL
No.393519
>>393503
exactly, the history of that profession is full of stories of trigger happy mercs literally raping the capital after they didn't get paid enough
WtepVc
No.393540
>>393503
Nlgger countries will fail regardless. They are an exception due to their low iq. No economic and political model is gonna help them. I am ancap but only at national level. Immigration should be banned especially from low iq countries. Only a populace with certain qualities can function in a society we are envisioning, so preserving demographics is a necessity.
WtepVc
No.393550
>>393492
You also get coups and military juntas in countries where army is state controlled. State control over army is no guarantee.
WtepVc
No.393565
>>393511
Also idc if large players exist. If they are that large in free market, they have earned that spot free and fair and people like their services.
pC2tCU
No.393636
>>393550
Mercs are inherently undisciplined and disloyal due to the nature of their job, besides even if you ignore that, Mercs can't be the primary fighting arm for a nation, since in the modern day military expenditure is so outrageously high they a private entity just can't form a large enough modern force. Modern warfare is more complex than a couple 1000 dudes with halberds and zweihanders looking for adventure and booty, indeed the simpler times are gone.
Just look at Blackwater and Wagner, the former was only capable of policing and garrison roles, the latter a private entity in just name, they completely relied on Russian military logistics, they might as well have been considered just an edgy branch of the Russian Army.
pC2tCU
No.393645
>>393636
ignore the stray 'they' in between
WtepVc
No.393674
>>393636
US army already has had contractual service aka tour of duty for quite some time now. We too have agnipath scheme. Its not such a novel idea. Just needs to be expanded. Again, socialist nlgger and arab countries have frequent coups. Myanmar has a military junta ruling it currently. Pakistan is ruled by army. If your populace is too low iq, undisciplined or you have systemic issues, you will have an unruly military leadership and political instability regardless of privatisation.
pC2tCU
No.393683
>>393674
I thought you were talking about full blown merc armies... contractual service is good.
SLtOgV
No.393691
>>393432(OP)
If priest king steps in to fix IAF procurement and brings PSU reforms to btfo babus he will single handedly become the greatest indian person to have lived post independence. You will not have to let Adani handle everything if PSUs were competent.
pC2tCU
No.393694
>>393683
not for India tho, America uses 8 yr(4 active duty) contracts because their primary recruits are kids looking for college money, having longer contracts would dissuade their primary recruit.
India has millions dying to join the army, longer service periods and experienced troops is the way for us. Agniveer is just gay dumbocratic wallet saving measures.
WtepVc
No.393710
>>393694
Contract can be extended for any private party the government deems fit to. Gormint isnt the problem in and of itself. The people can replace them through democratic right. Its the bureaucracy that isnt subject to it that needs to be substitited with private entities.
pC2tCU
No.393712
>>393710
explain in detail the kind of organization you are imagining because i think i'm misunderstanding u
WtepVc
No.393720
>>393712
You elect government every 5 years. They can choose to renew or not renew the expired contracts with pvt parties that previous governments had entered into. Army will be no different from any other private party. Arms will be owned by the state but the personnels who will be members of a private corp will be on contract.
pC2tCU
No.393763
>>393720
Who will control the armoury?
What even is the point of this? A contractual setup can be established under a traditional structure too without the chronic headache of a Merc mutiny, which for wtv you may cope with are inherently disloyal and untrustworthy because those are the kind of people this profession attracts.
WtepVc
No.393813
>>393763
>Who will control the armoury?
Army which will be controlled by defence ministry.
>What even is the point of this?
Efficiency. We need to get rid of permanent employment that state services provide.
>chronic headache of a Merc mutiny.
Coups have happened in socialist countries. Keeping army in check is the job of defence ministry regardless. The reason india hasnt had a coup and has free and fair elections is due to the self disciplined, democracy loving populace here and strong institutions. You are just paranoid. How has this country managed to stay a democracy for so long if it is so vulnerable?
pC2tCU
No.393826
>>393813
What do the private entities even do? You just seem adamant on introducing a baniya middleman.
>Coups have happened in socialist countries
Yaar, read up some history on these groups, no ruler who ever entrusted them had a good end.
>self disciplined, democracy loving populace here and strong institutions
It's rather because of ambitionless officers and soldiers with crab mentality and excellent internal intelligence networks, no one dares mention the c word even the deepest circles of the military establishment because some envious fag will certainly turn you in.
WtepVc
No.393841
>>393826
>private entities even do?
More efficient than bureaucracy.
>It's rather because of ambitionless officers and soldiers.
Its not just the military not taking over. Its also the peaceful transfer of power after free and fair elections and not falling into dictatorship that is impressive.
pC2tCU
No.393856
>>393841
More efficient at what?
